The American Scholar

Analysis of The American Scholar Poetry Submission Website

Positioning of the Site

The American Scholar is positioned as an elite-level literary magazine. It is a well-established publication, having been in circulation since 1932 and associated with the prestigious Phi Beta Kappa Society. The magazine primarily focuses on essays, fiction, and poetry that engage with public affairs, literature, science, history, and culture. Its acceptance rate for unsolicited submissions is notably low, at less than 2%, indicating a highly competitive environment suitable for established and emerging writers seeking recognition in the literary field[1][5][14].

Unique Advantages Compared to Similar Tier Journals

• Reputation and Credibility: As a publication linked to the Phi Beta Kappa Society, The American Scholar has a long-standing reputation for quality and intellectual rigor.

• Financial Compensation: The magazine offers competitive pay rates for accepted pieces—up to $500 for print publications and $250 for online-only submissions, which is higher than many other literary journals at a similar tier[1][5].

• Diverse Content: While many elite journals focus solely on poetry or fiction, The American Scholar includes a range of genres including essays and articles on significant cultural topics, providing a broader platform for writers[1][5].

Types of Poetry Works Suitable for Submission

The American Scholar accepts poetry that aligns with its broader thematic concerns. Suitable works include:

• Thoughtful and Engaging Poetry: Poems that explore themes relevant to public affairs, culture, or personal reflection are likely to resonate with the editorial vision.

• Innovative Forms: While traditional forms are welcome, innovative or experimental poems that challenge conventions may also find a place in the magazine's diverse offerings[1][5].

Requirements and Suggestions for Submitters

• Submission Format: All submissions must be made through Submittable; paper or email submissions are not accepted. Only one submission is allowed at a time.

• Cover Letter: A cover letter should include contact information, the genre of the submission, and any additional context about the work.

• Response Time: Submitters should expect a response time of several months due to the careful review process.

• Reading the Magazine: Prospective submitters are encouraged to read past issues to understand the types of poetry that resonate with the editors[1][4][5].

Alternative Sites for Submission if Rejected

If your submission to The American Scholar is rejected, consider these alternative poetry journals:

• Rattle: Known for its commitment to publishing diverse voices and styles, Rattle pays $100 per poem for online contributors and $200 for print contributors.

• Kenyon Review: This prestigious journal accepts poetry submissions year-round and has a strong reputation in literary circles.

• AGNI: Based at Boston University, AGNI seeks innovative poetry that pushes boundaries while also being accessible. They accept simultaneous submissions[7][8][14].

This analysis provides insight into The American Scholar's positioning in the literary landscape, its unique advantages, suitable poetry types, submission requirements, and alternative options for poets seeking publication.